Refined living room with a limestone hearth, pale oak floors and large windows overlooking ponderosa pines in late autumn.

What the Last New Homes Inside the Village at Castle Pines Cost Next to a Resale

On Vestal Peak Court, inside the gates of the Village at Castle Pines, a finished 5,202-square-foot Trumark home on lot 38 is ready for move-in. Its first price, $2,423,442, has been crossed out on the builder's page and replaced with $2,349,900. Two streets of the same project show the same pattern. That cut matters to anyone weighing a Village resale built in the 1980s or '90s. In a community that is nearly built out, a new home and an older one are now priced close enough that the older home's condition decides which one is the better buy.

The three new homes and the resale average, as of mid-November 2026

The Summit at Castle Pines is Trumark Homes' collection inside the gated Village. Plans run from about 4,116 to 6,277 square feet, and base pricing starts at $2,000,000. In mid-November 2026, three homes were listed on Trumark's Summit page.

Home Status on the builder page Price Square feet Price per sq. ft.
8038 Vestal Peak Court, Residence 3 Move-in ready, cut from $2,423,442 $2,349,900 5,202 about $452
8036 Golden Bear Lane, Residence 4 Listed for January 2027, cut from $2,423,626 $2,399,900 5,764 about $416
8045 Stewart Peak Place, Residence 1 Listed for November 2026 $2,599,900 4,459 about $583
Village-area resales, last 12 months 112 closed sales $1,981,017 average 4,955 average $387 average

The resale row comes from MLS data for the Village area covering the 12 months through mid-November 2026. Over that period, homes closed at an average of $1,981,017 and $387 a square foot, sold for 96.8% of list price, and took an average of 141 days to sell. The average resale had 4,955 square feet of living area, a little smaller than the Vestal Peak Court home.

The two larger Summit homes are the fair comparison. At about $452 a foot, the Vestal Peak Court home costs roughly $65 a foot more than the resale average, which is about $338,000 across its 5,202 square feet. At about $416 a foot, the Golden Bear Lane home is roughly $29 a foot above the average, or about $167,000 across 5,764 square feet. The smaller Residence 1 on Stewart Peak Place costs the most per foot because fixed costs like the lot and the three-car garage are spread over fewer square feet.

One caveat applies to every row. Trumark's plans include finished basements, so a per-foot comparison is only as good as the match between the finished space in each home.

Asking prices are ahead of closings

The listings tell a slightly different story from the closings. In mid-November 2026, the Village had 41 homes listed, with an average asking price of $437 a square foot, a median list price of $2,702,938, and an average of 114 days on the market. Over the past 12 months, closings averaged $387 a foot. Sellers are asking roughly what a new Summit home costs per foot, and buyers have been paying about $50 a foot less.

The pace explains the gap. The same 12-month data shows 42 active listings against 12 under contract, and 4.3 months of inventory. That sits between a seller's market below 4 months and a buyer's market above 6. Closings ranged from 4 in November 2025 to a peak of 13 in June 2026, with 8 in October 2026. At an average of 141 days to sell, buyers have time to compare a resale against Trumark's inventory, and the builder's own price cuts suggest Trumark sees the same pace.

For a resale owner, the competition inside the gates is a new home with a builder price that keeps moving. For a buyer, the starting number on a dated Village resale is the closing average, and asking prices are a less reliable guide.

The price gap is roughly a remodel budget

The Village was founded in the early 1980s, and 2026 is its 45th anniversary year. A resale at $387 a foot that needs $200,000 of work is close in cost to a Golden Bear Lane-size new home. A resale that needs $400,000 of work costs more than the Vestal Peak Court home. That math is the reason a resale's condition decides more about its value here than its price per foot does.

Local builders are already doing this work. Passero Signature Builders says it is currently building a custom home in the Village. Jackson Design Build completed a custom Village home in 2022 and markets remodeling there. Northstar Custom Homes advertises both custom builds and remodels in Castle Pines Village. Getting a bid from one of them before writing an offer turns the per-foot comparison into a firm number.

The Summit is close to the end of new construction inside the gates

What makes this comparison specific to the Village is how little new building is left. The homes association's December 18, 2025 board minutes counted 1,992 homes and an expected total of about 2,000 at build-out. They noted that 17 more Summit lots were platted in October 2025 and that one area along the first fairway was still to be platted. Trumark describes The Summit as 72 detached homes on quarter-acre lots.

That changes the resale math over time. While The Summit is selling, every older Village home is compared to a new one with a builder warranty, a known price and a delivery date. Once Trumark sells out and the fairway parcel is built, new construction inside the gates will mostly mean a remodel or a rebuild of an existing home. For now a buyer can choose between the two, and the price gap between them is narrow.

The community's infrastructure is also being sized for build-out. The Castle Pines Metropolitan District is building a second water storage tank, buried beside the existing one near Gate 5. It adds 2 million gallons to the current 2.5 million, and the district manager described it as added fire protection for the Village at full build-out. The February 2026 minutes put completion at the end of August 2026. The district also reported finishing $4 million of road projects in 2025.

The dues are the same for an old home and a new one

The homes association's 2026 assessments are $455 a month for custom lots and $341.25 a month for alternative lots. The last increase was in 2023. The association says its dues fund Emergency Services, trash collection and the upkeep of pools, trails and courts. Nineteen sub-associations are classified as cluster properties and charge additional dues. On the same type of lot, a 1988 custom home and a 2026 Summit home pay the same Village dues. Neither one has a cost advantage there, so the decision comes back to purchase price and renovation cost. These figures are general information and not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm the dues and any sub-association charges for a specific home with the right professional before you commit.

The dues also pay for amenity work. Phase One of the Canyon Club enhancement, a new splash pad and toddler pool, was finished in 2025. For 2026, the board approved a $303,437 rebuild of the pickleball and basketball courts and an $82,140 refresh of the locker rooms and family restroom. Phase Three, new pool slides, is planned for 2027 and 2028. The 2026 landscaping budget also includes a $76,000 rebuild of the Gate 4 water feature with native rock and recirculated water. A buyer of either an older home or a new one gets the same updated common areas.

Questions buyers ask about the Village

Is a Summit home more expensive than a Village resale? Per square foot, the two larger Summit homes listed in mid-November 2026 cost roughly $29 to $65 more than the 12-month resale average of $387. On a home of about 5,200 to 5,800 square feet, that works out to roughly $167,000 to $338,000.

Why do Village resales take so long to sell? Over the 12 months through mid-November 2026, closings averaged 141 days, and active listings outnumbered pending sales 42 to 12. Average asking prices of $437 a foot ran well ahead of the $387 average closing price, and homes that closed sold for 96.8% of list.

Will there be more new construction inside the gates after The Summit? The homes association's December 2025 minutes put the Village at 1,992 homes, with one area along the first fairway still to be platted and an expected total of about 2,000.

If you own a Village home from the 1980s or '90s and want to know how it compares with what Trumark is charging down the road, or you're a buyer deciding between a resale that needs work and a new Summit home, I'd be glad to walk through the comparison with you at Lara Property Group. Get your instant home valuation, then talk with me about what the gap means for your plans in Castle Pines.

A Higher Standard

At Lara Property Group, we don’t just buy and sell real estate—we curate seamless, high-end experiences for our clients. Our expertise in Denver’s luxury and commercial markets ensures that every decision is informed, strategic, and tailored to your unique goals.

Follow Me on Instagram